ISLAMABAD: The Federal Constitutional Court (FCC) has declared infrastructure cesses imposed by the Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa governments unconstitutional, ruling that the provincial legislatures exceeded their authority by taxing goods and transactions falling within the federal government’s exclusive jurisdiction.
A two-member bench comprising Chief Justice Aminuddin Khan and Justice Aamer Farooq announced the decision on Thursday after hearing 568 petitions challenging the legality of infrastructure levies imposed by the two provincial governments.
The ruling overturned earlier judgments of the Sindh High Court and Peshawar High Court, both of which had upheld the respective provincial laws.
The petitions challenged the Sindh Development and Maintenance of Infrastructure Cess Act, 2017, and the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Infrastructure Development Cess Act, 2022, including amendments introduced through the KP Finance Act, 2024.
The central constitutional question concerned whether provincial assemblies could impose infrastructure-related charges on the movement of goods when the taxable transactions involved matters reserved for federal legislation.
After examining the relevant constitutional provisions and arguments presented by the parties, the FCC concluded that the challenged levies exceeded the legislative competence of the provincial assemblies.
The court held that provincial governments could not impose taxes on activities constitutionally assigned to the federal government merely by describing those charges as infrastructure development cesses.
The Sindh legislation imposed a levy on goods entering or leaving the province through international air and sea routes.
The dispute surrounding the Sindh infrastructure cess dates back to 1994 and has remained the subject of prolonged litigation involving businesses, importers and provincial authorities.
On June 4, 2021, the Sindh High Court upheld the levy, finding in favour of the provincial government’s authority to impose the charge.
However, that decision was subsequently challenged before the Federal Constitutional Court.
In Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, the infrastructure development cess applied to the transportation and movement of goods within the province.
The provincial government introduced the levy under the Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Infrastructure Development Cess Act, 2022.
An amendment through the KP Finance Act, 2024, increased the applicable cess rate from 1% to 2%.
The legislation was challenged through multiple petitions, with businesses and other affected parties questioning the constitutional basis of the charge.
On November 14, 2025, the Peshawar High Court dismissed 157 petitions against the KP infrastructure cess and declared the legislation legally valid.
The FCC’s latest judgment has now set aside that ruling along with the corresponding Sindh High Court decision.
During proceedings, petitioners argued that the provincial governments had imposed taxes on transactions involving imports, exports and inter-provincial trade.
They maintained that such matters were constitutionally reserved for Parliament and could not be subjected to provincial taxation beyond the powers granted under the Constitution.
Senior counsel Hafiz Ehsaan Ahmad Khokhar represented the secretary of the Revenue Division and the Federal Board of Revenue (FBR).
He argued that Articles 141 and 142(a) of the Constitution, read together with Entries 27, 43 and 59 of the Federal Legislative List, established the federation’s exclusive legislative authority over the relevant customs-related and taxation matters.
According to the federation’s position, the constitutional validity of a levy must be determined by examining its actual operation and the transaction being taxed.
The government argued that simply naming a charge an infrastructure cess did not establish provincial authority if the levy effectively operated as a tax on imported or exported goods.
Khokhar maintained that provincial levies collected through customs-clearance mechanisms or linked directly to import and export transactions could interfere with federal taxation powers.
He also referred to Article 163 of the Constitution, which allows provincial governments to impose taxes on professions, trades, callings and employments.
However, he argued that the provision did not authorise provincial assemblies to legislate on matters expressly reserved for Parliament.
The federation’s position was supported by the additional attorney general, who maintained that the disputed infrastructure levies fell within areas of exclusive federal legislative competence.
The Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa governments defended their respective laws during the proceedings.
Provincial representatives argued that the cesses were intended to finance infrastructure development, road maintenance and facilities required for the movement of goods.
They maintained that the charges were not customs duties or export taxes but provincial revenue measures designed to support infrastructure used by commercial transport.
The provinces also relied on Article 142(c) of the Constitution, which empowers provincial assemblies to legislate on matters that do not fall within the Federal Legislative List.
Their position was that infrastructure development and related provincial facilities came within their legislative jurisdiction.
The FCC, however, accepted the constitutional objections to the challenged legislation and ruled that the provinces had exceeded their lawmaking authority.
The judgment reinforces the constitutional distinction between federal and provincial taxation powers, particularly where levies are imposed on goods associated with international or inter-provincial commercial activity.
The decision could have implications for businesses involved in importing, exporting and transporting goods through Sindh and Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.
However, the supplied account of the ruling does not specify whether the court issued separate directions concerning previously collected cess amounts, refund claims or the treatment of pending recoveries.
Those matters would require examination of the court’s detailed written judgment and any subsequent implementation directions.
The ruling also raises broader questions about how provincial governments may finance infrastructure development without imposing charges that conflict with federal legislative powers.
Although provinces retain constitutional authority to legislate and collect revenue within their permitted areas, the FCC’s decision establishes that such powers cannot extend to subjects reserved for the federation.
By setting aside the judgments of both high courts, the Federal Constitutional Court has resolved the constitutional challenges against the disputed Sindh and KP infrastructure cess laws in favour of the petitioners.
The decision marks a significant development in Pakistan’s constitutional and taxation framework, with potential consequences for provincial revenue measures and commercial activity involving the movement of goods.
You may also like
-
Maryam Nawaz Reaffirms Commitment to Child Welfare on World Children’s Day
-
Pakistan India UN Dispute: Islamabad Rejects Indian Remarks, Raises Terrorism and Water Treaty Concerns
-
Pakistan Qatar Security Cooperation: Countries Sign MoU and Anti-Drug Action Plan
-
NationalGrid-Pakistan Plans Rs100 Billion Sukuk Programme to Strengthen Electricity Transmission Network
-
Pakistan LNG Imports: Government Plans 16 Cargoes to Meet Winter Gas Demand