ISLAMABAD: The Federal Board of Revenue (FBR) has introduced a faceless appeals framework for sales tax and federal excise disputes and proposed similar reforms for income tax cases, aiming to improve transparency, impartiality and efficiency in Pakistan’s tax dispute resolution system.
The changes were outlined in two notifications issued on November 18, 2026. SRO 2134(I)/2026 amends the Sales Tax Rules, 2006, while SRO 2136(I)/2026 proposes amendments to the Income Tax Rules, 2002.
Under the new arrangements, eligible tax appeals will be submitted electronically through FBR’s Iris portal or another designated digital platform.
Cases will then be distributed among appellate units through a random, dynamic and automated allocation system, replacing manual assignment for appeals covered by the framework.
A central feature of the reforms is the anonymity of commissioners responsible for deciding appeals.
The identities of appellate units and commissioners will remain concealed from taxpayers, their authorised representatives and the respondent tax authorities throughout the proceedings, including after final decisions are issued.
During virtual hearings, commissioners will not appear on camera, while their voices will be electronically modified to prevent identification.
The system is designed to reduce opportunities for inappropriate influence and direct contact between parties and officials responsible for determining tax disputes.
Both notifications provide for hearings through video conferencing facilities or secure electronic communication systems.
Notices, written arguments, evidence, supporting documents and other correspondence will be exchanged digitally, eliminating the requirement for physical appearances before the deciding commissioner.
Taxpayers will also have the option of requesting decisions based entirely on written submissions.
However, the relevant tax authority must be given an opportunity to provide comments, while the appellant will retain the right to respond.
To accommodate taxpayers without reliable internet access, the FBR has provided for participation in electronic hearings through designated facilities at the nearest Field Operations Wing office.
These offices will assist taxpayers in attending proceedings remotely.
The sales tax framework applies to specified appeals processed through the National Faceless Centre under Section 45C of the Sales Tax Act, 1990.
It includes appeals against orders issued by officers appointed within the Centre and other categories that may subsequently be notified by the FBR.
The same arrangements extend to eligible federal excise appeals under Section 33 of the Federal Excise Act, 2005.
For income tax disputes, the proposed rules cover appeals under Section 127 of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001, processed through the relevant Centre under Section 129A.
Both frameworks establish dedicated Appeals Wings comprising appellate units headed by commissioners.
Administrative supervision will rest with the FBR’s Member (Legal) Inland Revenue.
However, other authorities within the respective centres will not be permitted to influence commissioners in the hearing or determination of individual appeals.
The notifications also introduce safeguards intended to prevent conflicts of interest.
Officials who conducted the original audit, assessment or quality control process, or issued the disputed order, will be prohibited from deciding an appeal against that decision.
Commissioners with personal or financial interests in a case must disclose the conflict electronically and withdraw from the proceedings.
The appeal will subsequently be reassigned to another appellate unit.
The FBR or the relevant centre may transfer cases between units to balance workloads and maintain administrative efficiency.
However, once a hearing has commenced, any transfer must be supported by reasons recorded in writing.
In such circumstances, the appellant may request a fresh hearing before the newly assigned commissioner.
The revised procedures also address applications seeking suspension of tax recovery during appeal proceedings.
Under the sales tax framework, applications for a stay of recovery must be scheduled for an electronic hearing no later than the second working day after receipt.
The commissioner must decide the application within seven working days from the date the hearing is fixed.
For income tax cases, the proposed amendments refer to the existing timelines under Rule 76G of the Income Tax Rules rather than establishing separate deadlines.
Respondent tax authorities will generally be required to submit paragraph-wise comments electronically within seven days of receiving a request, unless the commissioner allows a different period.
Where additional evidence or physical verification is necessary, the relevant Field Operations Wing will examine the material and upload its findings to the digital system.
This arrangement will allow proceedings to continue without requiring the parties to appear physically before the commissioner deciding the appeal.
The sales tax amendments further clarify that additional enquiries conducted during appellate proceedings will not authorise the remanding of a case for fresh consideration.
Electronic hearings will be recorded and archived as part of the official case record.
Final decisions, notices and directions will be generated through the FBR’s computerised system and authenticated using a Digital Identification Number (DIN).
The commissioner’s name, designation and signature will not appear on the issued documents.
Under the sales tax rules, orders uploaded to a taxpayer’s electronic folder will be considered properly served.
The proposed income tax provisions similarly recognise electronic delivery through the taxpayer’s designated account.
Where a taxpayer subsequently approaches the Appellate Tribunal, the disputed decision will be identified through its appeal number and DIN rather than the name of the commissioner who issued it.
The notifications also preserve existing statutory provisions allowing eligible taxpayers to approach the Appellate Tribunal directly.
Appeals already pending before commissioners when the new framework becomes applicable will generally continue with those officers unless the FBR orders their transfer.
If a pending case is transferred, proceedings will resume from the stage previously reached.
The framework also addresses technical disruptions that could prevent taxpayers from meeting statutory filing deadlines.
An electronic portal failure confirmed by the FBR, which prevents the timely submission of an appeal, application or reply, will be treated as sufficient cause under the relevant legal provisions governing filing delays.
The sales tax and federal excise amendments will take effect on dates separately notified by the FBR.
The Board may establish different commencement dates for different categories of appeals.
Meanwhile, the proposed income tax amendments remain in draft form, with the FBR allowing three days from publication in the official Gazette for objections and suggestions.
The reforms represent a significant move towards digital administration of tax appeals, with automated case allocation, anonymous decision-makers and electronic documentation intended to strengthen confidence in the dispute resolution process.
Their effectiveness will depend on reliable digital infrastructure, consistent implementation and safeguards that preserve taxpayers’ rights to fair hearings and independent appellate decisions.
You may also like
-
Saudi Firm Restarts Bid for Samba Bank Majority
-
Engro Fertilizers: Partnership With Waseela Aims to Improve Crop Nutrition and Farmer Productivity
-
Pakistan Freelance Exports: Earnings Hit Record $210 Million in October 2026
-
Pakistan Fertiliser Industry: Manufacturers Seek Long-Term Gas Supply and Nutrient-Based Subsidies
-
Pakistan Money Laundering: Rs60 Billion Allegedly Routed Through Solar Panel Imports